For more than a decade, payment innovation has been framed as a transition from physical to digital money. Yet the latest findings from the Federal Reserve reveal a different reality: consumers are not choosing between cash and digital payments. They are choosing both.
According to the 2026 Diary of Consumer Payment Choice, cash remains an integral part of Americans’ financial lives. Four out of five consumers continue to use cash, 90% report having no plans to stop using it, and nearly half now keep cash on hand for savings or emergency preparedness. The study also found that Americans made an average of 47 payments per month in 2025, with cash accounting for 14% of all payments, making it the nation’s third most frequently used payment method. These findings demonstrate that while payment technologies continue to evolve, consumers continue to value flexibility and maintain a mix of payment options rather than relying on a single method.
Consumer behavior tells a different story than technology headlines
Innovation in payments has been extraordinary. Digital wallets have become mainstream, peer-to-peer transfers are nearly instantaneous, and consumers can complete purchases with a tap of a phone or smartwatch.
The Federal Reserve’s decade of consumer payment research suggests payment habits evolve gradually rather than abruptly. New technologies expand the range of payment choices available to consumers, but they do not necessarily replace existing methods that continue to serve distinct purposes. Consumers continue to use cash because it offers characteristics that digital payments cannot fully replicate. It is universally accepted, immediately accessible, requires no technology or internet connection, and functions independently of third-party networks or electrical infrastructure.
Cash remains a trusted foundation for payment resilience
Perhaps the most significant finding from the Federal Reserve’s latest research is not simply that Americans continue to use cash, but why they keep it. The growing number of consumers holding cash for emergencies reflects a broader recognition that digital systems, while highly reliable, are not immune to disruption.
The research found that 76% of consumers carried cash during 2025, while 45% stored cash separately for savings or emergencies. Average emergency cash holdings increased from $306 in 2024 to $364 in 2025, suggesting that more consumers view physical currency as an important component of financial preparedness.
This behavior highlights an important aspect of payment choice: consumers value not only convenience, but also reliability and control. Power outages, severe weather events, cyber incidents, telecommunications failures, and network disruptions can temporarily limit access to electronic payment systems. During these moments, cash provides immediate continuity because it functions independently of electricity, internet connectivity, and third-party networks.
For many consumers, that resilience creates trust. Cash settles instantly, remains directly accessible, and works regardless of technology availability. Interestingly, while only 16% of consumers identified cash as their preferred in-person payment method, many more continue to use it regularly. This suggests that cash increasingly serves as a trusted and dependable fallback option, even for consumers who primarily rely on cards or digital payments.
Rather than indicating resistance to innovation, these findings demonstrate that consumers value having multiple reliable ways to pay. As payment systems become increasingly digital and interconnected, maintaining access to cash remains an important component of resilience, helping ensure continuity, confidence, and choice across a wide range of circumstances.
The future is coexistence, not competition
Too often, discussions about payment innovation are framed as a competition between physical and digital money. In reality, successful payment ecosystems are built on coexistence.
Central banks, financial institutions, retailers and payment providers all share an interest in ensuring that consumers can access reliable payment options across a wide range of circumstances. This means supporting innovation while maintaining the resilience of existing infrastructure.
Demographic trends provide additional insight. The Federal Reserve’s research also highlights that cash use remains higher among older adults, lower-income households, and rural communities. These findings underscore that maintaining access to cash continues to support accessibility and payment choice across diverse segments of the population.
Planning for resilience requires preserving payment choice
The lesson from the Federal Reserve’s latest research is clear. Building the future of payments is not about choosing between physical and digital forms of money. It is about creating a resilient ecosystem in which consumers can rely on both. As payment systems continue to evolve, preserving access to cash remains an essential part of ensuring trust, continuity, and choice for all Americans.
About the Author: Jim Petit leads the Currency Management Solutions division for Giesecke+Devrient (G+D) in the United States. With decades of experience across payments and financial services, he brings a perspective shaped by G+D’s work with central banks and financial institutions in over 100 countries. For more information, please visit www.gi-de.com.
